A 43-year-old Southern California woman who slashed her boyfriend's throat and buried his body in what police called a "makeshift tomb" in her backyard has been sentenced to 15 years in prison. The corpse stayed there for eight years before anyone found it.
Trista Spicer was sentenced Friday in San Bernardino Superior Court after a jury late last year found her guilty of second-degree murder in the October 2014 killing of her boyfriend, Eric Mercado, 42. The San Bernardino Sheriff's Department is holding Spicer in the county jail until her expected transfer to a California state prison.
According to news outlets, the killing began after Mercado complained about the dinner Spicer served him. What followed was not a momentary act of panic.
Spicer testified during the trial that she struck Mercado in the head several times with a cast-iron skillet. She then stabbed him in the neck with a kitchen knife he had dropped after she struck him with the skillet. The sequence matters. This was not a single blow in a struggle. It was repeated blunt force trauma followed by a fatal stabbing.
What came next reveals something colder than the killing itself. Spicer enlisted a friend to help her wrap the corpse in a deflated air mattress. She then concealed the body in her backyard, where it remained undiscovered while Mercado's family searched for answers. His family had reported him missing since 2014, as Breitbart reports.
For eight years, a family grieved a disappearance that was never a disappearance at all.
The case broke open in 2022, and the circumstances of its unraveling are as jarring as the crime itself. According to the San Bernardino Sun, Spicer told her boyfriend at the time that she needed to remove Mercado's corpse because her family wanted to sell the house. Not guilt. Not confession. Real estate logistics.
Police acted on a search warrant of the property and discovered what they described as a makeshift tomb on the grounds. After eight years buried in a backyard, Mercado's remains finally told the story his family had been desperate to hear.
Mercado's sister, Mahira Torres, addressed the court during Friday's proceedings and called Spicer "evil." Her victim impact statement carried the weight of nearly a decade of not knowing.
"You took my brother's life, and you shattered ours."
There is no rebuttal to that. There is no mitigating context that erases what Torres and her family endured: years of searching, years of wondering, while the woman responsible for their brother's death walked free and lived in the same house where she had buried him.
Spicer testified that Mercado had a history of physically and verbally abusing her, and that he often made her sit naked for long periods as part of his punishing and controlling behavior. This was her defense. The jury weighed it.
They returned a verdict of second-degree murder.
Domestic abuse is real, and its toll on victims is serious. But a jury heard the full testimony, evaluated the evidence, and concluded that what happened in October 2014 was murder. The post-killing conduct tells its own story. A person acting in genuine self-defense does not typically enlist help to wrap a body in a deflated air mattress, bury it in the backyard, and maintain silence for eight years while the victim's family files missing persons reports.
Concealment is not the behavior of someone who believes they had no other choice. It is the behavior of someone who believes they could avoid consequences.
Fifteen years for taking a life and hiding it for nearly a decade. Torres called Spicer evil. The justice system called it second-degree murder. Whether 15 years adequately accounts for the killing itself, plus the calculated concealment, plus the years of anguish inflicted on a family left searching, is a question the sentence invites but does not answer.
Eric Mercado's family spent eight years looking for a man who was buried a few feet from where his killer slept. They deserve better than closure. They deserved the truth in 2014. They got it in 2022 because someone wanted to sell a house.
